?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Gacked from tracy_rowan

I believe fandom must be fun for everybody. Sometimes it's not, unfortunately. These are good suggestions to follow this year in order to be happy with your OTPs and other fans, everywhere.


The Fan/Fandom Creed

I. I acknowledge that fandom can, has, and will exist without me. I am not important. What I can do, someone else could easily take over. Even if the fandom is tiny, there are probably many more fans of whom I simply have not heard that write/draw/dream things that could blow my mind. Fandom would not fall apart without me.

II. I acknowledge that no matter what I've contributed to it, the fandom owes me absolutely nothing. I will not look for fame, nor will I expect a certain type of treatment from anyone else in the fandom. If people respect me, let them; if people dislike me, let them. I certainly will not threaten to leave and expect anyone to care.

III. I acknowledge that no matter what sort of "credentials" I have in the real world, in fandom, I am merely just another "fan." I might be a published author, a famous artist, or hell, Brad Pitt, but in fandom, if I am not the creator of the canon material, I am merely a follower and I will remember that.

IV. I acknowledge that fandom is a thing created and kept alive by more than one person. People will disagree with me; I will disagree with people. Although I reserve the right to leave the premises or disagree/rant/make snide comments in relative private, I will never flame someone publically or personally for their opinions. If there is discussion in public, it will be civil and I will keep the peace.

V. I acknowledge that there will always be parts of fandom that I dislike; I also acknowledge that there will always be parts of fandom that dislike me; these parts, I will ignore. There will always be people who will never see things my way, no matter what anyone says or does, and there will always be people who keep producing works with which I completely disagree. Again, although I reserve the right to leave the premises or disagree/rant/make snide comments in relative private, I will make no move to actually stop them. They have the right to imagine their versions of characters, just as I have the right to imagine mine.

VI. I acknowledge that, just as fandom owes me nothing, neither do other fans. It doesn't matter who I am; just because I created a community or many people agree with my portrayal of Character A does not give me rights to anything in the fandom. If I receive praise, I will always remember that it is given freely, not due; if I receive criticism, I will take it and remember that criticism, too, is freely given. Regardless of which it is, I will always feel thankful for the time.

VII. I acknowledge that fandom is fandom and how certain people act/how certain people's tastes run in fandom has no relation to them in real life. Although I reserve the right to like or dislike someone based on their OOC/non-fandom-related comments, I will neither judge nor form opinions about someone as a person purely through fandom. Just as slash writers are not always gay and RPers are not always self-inserts, I acknowledge that the fandom-image I know and the real life-person that I do not may be completely different people.

VIII. I acknowledge that there will be other fans that I dislike personally; I also acknowledge that there will be other fans that dislike me personally; these fans, I will ignore. Again, although I reserve the right to leave the premises or disagree/rant/make snide comments in relative private, I will make no move to actually confront them if they have done no wrong. Being a jerk may have them kicked out of communities and forums, but I will always remember that they have as much right to be in the actual fandom as I do. And I will always remember that I do have that right.

IX. I acknowledge that just as I am in fandom to have fun, other people are in fandom for the exact same reason, and I will remember that. I will never do anything to actively try to stop other people's fun, regardless of how much I may disagree with what they are doing. Clause reserving the right to leave the premises or disagree/rant/make snide comments in relative private still holds here, but I will never tell another fan to stop having fun in whatever way they want to have fun. And I will never pay any attention when someone tells me to stop having fun myself.

X. I acknowledge that just as everyone else is a person, that I am a person, too. No matter what other fans may think of me from what they have seen in fandom, I will never let that persona/image/reputation get in the way of being myself if/when I should communicate with them outside of fandom. If they respect me, I will thank them, and if they dislike me, I will accept it, but these things I will strictly keep in fandom only and will not allow them to interfere with my friendships or real life.

XI. I acknowledge that there are people uninterested in my fandom and I will not press my fandom upon them. I will not speak of certain fandoms to those that have no interest in them, nor will I pressure anyone to look at/read/otherwise be forced to come up with reactions to things that they couldn't care less about. I know that fandoms are very specific things, that being pressured into looking at them is highly uncomfortable, and I will not impose that way upon others.

XII. I acknowledge that, in the end, real life is real life and fandom is only fandom. If fandom begins to affects my real life in negative ways, I will remember that I have the option to simply leave and if it gets bad enough, I will. If I am truly unhappy with a certain fandom or the way a certain fandom is going, I will remember that I have the option of simply creating another community for people who share the same interests as me, or the option of just staying and refusing to go with the flow. I will remember that fandom is a simple trade of time with fun, and that if the fun is not worth the cost, I will remember that I am merely wasting time. Above all else, I will remember that remaining in fandom is an entirely voluntary action.

If you follow this creed, please post it in your journal.

Comments

( 6 comments — Leave a comment )
soitg0es
Jan. 7th, 2006 02:49 am (UTC)
I find number XII quite interesting, since QAF fandom has been in 'self-destructive' mode in the past few (?) weeks with on-going bad!fic awards and people pointing fingers (and laughing) at other people.....it's all become pretty nasty. Even though I'm not participating in it in any way, I find MYSELF ridiculed by some of the comments for the simple reason that I've been enjoying some of the stuff that a few 'experts' took upon themselves to label 'not good enough' or whatever. There are people openly admitting to feeling uneasy at leaving comments, since they, too, then feel ridiculed if a certain fic they like gets spit on. And to think that it's supposed to be fun... *le sigh* I don't remember things being this nasty with Oz. And Oz was - supposedly - nasty, haha. *shakes head*
adrianabr
Jan. 11th, 2006 12:34 am (UTC)
I finally discovered your new identity, lol - better later than never, I suppose. See, I quite don't understand all the fuss that happens from time to time in fandoms in general. I mean, everybody has strong opinions and POVs concerning to their favorite characters but that's what they are, characters. OK, it's important to fight for what you think is right but flaming people because they don't think like you? Starting hate threads for the same reason? Stalking people through internet because of it? Unbelievable. There are people at Oz fandom that I love and there are (very) few ones that I don't. I don't agree to their ideas, I feel umconfortable whenever they pop up at TS or at another LJ commenting and spreading their thoughts. Am I going to flame them? No. I ignore them, which I think it's quite better. Not too long ago there was a lot of nonsense going on at TS, suggestions for fics and comments that made me want to cry, and I think they made other people want to cry too (you know about who I'm talking, the older fans, *g*). But everybody was clever enough to not discuss or argue about those subjects and they were forgotten, thank God. I prefer things that way, really.
(but of course I understand when people can't stay silent and let stupid ones ruin everybody's fun, I'm just a chicken who can't do that by myself!)
soitg0es
Jan. 11th, 2006 11:13 am (UTC)
Yes, they're supposed to be JUST characters. I don't mind if people don't want to stop at 'just characters' -- what I do mind is lack of tolerance and sanity, when it comes to it. *g* I mean, it's basic psychology, really - the way each and every one of us sees the characters - as is the case in RL. Everyone has different perception of people. People I like and attribute the best of qualities to might be average to you and you might not like them at all, which depends on our personally experiences with people in general. In the same way, depending on out personal likes and/or dislikes, we're more likely to sort of disregard some OOC qualities authors attribute to the characters based on their own visions, if we share that vision. (Now I'm going all Matrix on myself, haha - is what you see REALLY what you see? ;P) It's understandable that, at that point, somebody with a different vision will find that certain quality OOC. What's so complicated about that?!
There are quite a few B/J fics in which Justin likes being spanked (and Brian enjoys spanking him, of course), which is - imo - a major OOC, 'cause I just don't see Brian EVER hurting Justin, not even for sexual pleasure, given their history and everything Justin's been through. My opinion is built on my own preferences, of course - I'm quite 'vanilla' like that. ;P
So instead of seeking authors who share their 'vision of (the) character', these weirdos who can't tolerate different ideas choose to go witch-hunting. (I quote) 'bad!fic(s) hurt their eyes and make their brain explode', but do they stop? Hell no! They organize bad!fic awards and such. That's not sadism, that's masochism. *lol*
I'm with you on the 'ignoring'. At first I felt the URGE to say something reasonable, but it's really futile in the end. People will still like what they like, and still force their own standards as to what is and what's not OOC. I'll still stay away.
You know, I can't but remember the time when my precious "Longing" stirred that character discussion at TS. 'Was Keller the wiser one.(?)' I felt quite uneasy, really - proud to have 'provoked' people to come up and discuss, but definitely uneasy, too. I'm all for 'moderately passionate'! ;) But it was NOTHING like this thing with QAF.
soitg0es
Jan. 7th, 2006 03:45 am (UTC)
And some "fandom wank"...
adrianabr
Jan. 11th, 2006 12:35 am (UTC)
Oh my... ::cries::
soitg0es
Jan. 11th, 2006 08:27 am (UTC)
Exactly.
( 6 comments — Leave a comment )